Homeowners Insurance Review💎 Best for High-Value Homes

Chubb Masterpiece Homeowners Insurance

Chubb

Guaranteed replacement cost, high-value dwelling, fine art/jewelry scheduling & cash-out claim settlement. Premiums are quoted individually.

At a Glance

Category

Homeowners Insurance

Premium

Personalized quote only

AM Best Rating

A++

Coverage Type

Guaranteed replacement cost, high-value dwelling, fine art/jewelry scheduling & cash-out claim settlement

Term / Plan Type

Masterpiece® high-value homeowners policy

What a homeowners policy is made of

Chubb describes this coverage as “Guaranteed replacement cost, high-value dwelling, fine art/jewelry scheduling & cash-out claim settlement” (Masterpiece® high-value homeowners policy). Here is what each part does, so you can judge a Chubb quote line by line.

  • Dwelling (Coverage A). Rebuilds the house itself. Insure to the estimated cost to rebuild, not the market price, which includes land.
  • Other structures (B). Detached garages, fences and sheds — often set at 10% of dwelling coverage.
  • Personal property (C). Your belongings. Replacement-cost coverage pays to buy new items; actual-cash-value coverage subtracts depreciation.
  • Loss of use (D). Extra living costs while the home is repaired after a covered loss.
  • Liability and medical payments (E, F). Injuries to others and damage you cause, plus small medical bills for guests regardless of fault.

Getting a fair comparison on a Chubb quote

  • Compare the dwelling limit each insurer proposes — a lower rebuild estimate makes a quote look cheaper.
  • Check whether wind, hail or hurricane damage has a separate percentage deductible.
  • Confirm whether personal property is covered at replacement cost and whether water backup and service-line coverage are included.

Financial strength ratings

Chubb is rated A++ by AM Best. AM Best's financial strength scale runs from A++ and A+ (Superior) through A and A− (Excellent) and B++ and B+ (Good) down to weaker grades. A rating measures the insurer's ability to pay claims, not its price or service; your state insurance department publishes complaint data that covers the service side.

Other home insurers we cover

InsurerCoverage listedAM Best
Chubb Masterpiece Homeowners InsuranceGuaranteed replacement cost, high-value dwelling, fine art/jewelry scheduling & cash-out claim settlementA++
Allstate Home InsuranceDwelling, personal property, liability & loss of useA+
Travelers Home InsuranceDwelling, personal property, liability & water backupA++
Nationwide Home InsuranceDwelling, personal property, liability, loss of use & Brand New BelongingsA+
Farmers Home InsuranceDwelling, personal property, liability, loss of use & identity theft add-onA
USAA Homeowners InsuranceDwelling, personal property, liability, loss of use & military uniform/equipment coverageA++
State Farm Homeowners InsuranceHomeowners coverage for dwelling, contents and liability, sold through local State Farm agentsCheck AM Best

Coverage descriptions as listed by each insurer when last verified. Prices are not compared because they depend on your location and profile.

Tools and guides for this decision

$1,000 vs. $2,500 deductible →Is the premium saving worth it?Replacement cost vs. ACV →What a claim would actually pay.Percentage deductibles →Wind, hail and hurricane deductibles explained.

Key Features

Guaranteed replacement cost with no coverage cap

Risk Consulting services including wildfire and water-damage mitigation

Cash settlement option lets you rebuild elsewhere or bank the payout

Pros & Cons

Pros

  • Superior (A++) financial strength backing large claims
  • Extensive valuable-articles and collections coverage
  • White-glove risk-engineering and loss-prevention services

Tradeoffs

  • Not designed for standard or lower-value homes
  • Requires an agent/broker — no instant self-serve online quote

Best for: Owners of high-value homes ($750K+) with valuable collections

Premiums shown are illustrative national averages as of 2026 and vary by state, coverage limits, and personal risk factors — get a personalized quote directly from the provider.

← Compare all insurance plans