SmartRates research · Published November 9, 2026

Which credit card pays a typical household the most? Usually not the one with the fee

We applied what the average US household spends on groceries, dining, gas, travel and everyday purchases to the 35 personal cards whose fees and reward rates we’ve verified. Only 2 of 13 annual-fee cards earn more after the fee than the best no-fee card, and at half that spending only 1 do.

Top card, after fee

$848

American Express® Gold Card, $325 fee

Best no-fee card

$535

Wells Fargo Active Cash® Card

Fee cards that win

2 of 13

Annual-fee cards that beat the best no-fee card

Household card spending

$26,766

A year, BLS 2025 averages mapped to reward categories

Key findings

  • On average household card spending ($26,766 a year), the top card is the American Express® Gold Card: $848 a year after its $325 fee.
  • The best no-fee card, the Wells Fargo Active Cash® Card, earns $535, $313 less than the top card.
  • Fees are sensitive to spending: at half the average, the American Express® Gold Card falls to #4 ($262), and Wells Fargo Active Cash® Card is the best no-fee pick at $268.
  • Welcome bonuses are excluded. They can make a fee card worth it in year one, but this study measures what you earn every year after.

Net rewards after fee, top 10

Net annual rewards after annual fee for the top 10 cards on average household spendingAmerican Express® Gold Card: $848 a year after a $325 fee ($1,173 rewards); Citi Strata Premier® Card: $807 a year after a $95 fee ($902 rewards); Wells Fargo Active Cash® Card: $535 a year after no annual fee ($535 rewards); Navy Federal More Rewards American Express® Card: $530 a year after no annual fee ($530 rewards); Blue Cash Preferred® Card from Amex: $523 a year after a $95 fee ($618 rewards); Citi Strata℠ Card: $489 a year after no annual fee ($489 rewards); Capital One Savor Rewards: $480 a year after no annual fee ($480 rewards); Chase Freedom Unlimited®: $464 a year after no annual fee ($464 rewards); Wells Fargo Autograph® Card: $452 a year after no annual fee ($452 rewards); Capital One Venture Rewards: $440 a year after a $95 fee ($535 rewards)$0$200$400$600$800$1000American Express® Gold Card: $848 a year after a $325 fee ($1,173 rewards)American Express® Gold Card$848Citi Strata Premier® Card: $807 a year after a $95 fee ($902 rewards)Citi Strata Premier® Card$807Wells Fargo Active Cash® Card: $535 a year after no annual fee ($535 rewards)Wells Fargo Active Cash® Card$535Navy Federal More Rewards American Express® Card: $530 a year after no annual fee ($530 rewards)Navy Federal More Rewards American Express® Card$530Blue Cash Preferred® Card from Amex: $523 a year after a $95 fee ($618 rewards)Blue Cash Preferred® Card from Amex$523Citi Strata℠ Card: $489 a year after no annual fee ($489 rewards)Citi Strata℠ Card$489Capital One Savor Rewards: $480 a year after no annual fee ($480 rewards)Capital One Savor Rewards$480Chase Freedom Unlimited®: $464 a year after no annual fee ($464 rewards)Chase Freedom Unlimited®$464Wells Fargo Autograph® Card: $452 a year after no annual fee ($452 rewards)Wells Fargo Autograph® Card$452Capital One Venture Rewards: $440 a year after a $95 fee ($535 rewards)Capital One Venture Rewards$440
$26,766 a year of card spending (BLS 2025 averages). Net = rewards minus annual fee; welcome bonuses excluded.

Top 10 on average household spending

$26,766 a year of card spending (BLS 2025 averages). Net rate = net rewards ÷ spending. Select a column heading to sort.
1American Express® Gold Card$325$1,173$8483.17%
2Citi Strata Premier® Card$95$902$8073.01%
3Wells Fargo Active Cash® CardNone$535$5352.00%
4Navy Federal More Rewards American Express® CardNone$530$5301.98%
5Blue Cash Preferred® Card from Amex$95$618$5231.95%
6Citi Strata℠ CardNone$489$4891.83%
7Capital One Savor RewardsNone$480$4801.79%
8Chase Freedom Unlimited®None$464$4641.73%
9Wells Fargo Autograph® CardNone$452$4521.69%
10Capital One Venture Rewards$95$535$4401.65%

Top 10 at half that spending

$13,383 a year: the same mix, halved. Select a column heading to sort.
1Citi Strata Premier® Card$95$451$3562.66%
2Wells Fargo Active Cash® CardNone$268$2682.00%
3Navy Federal More Rewards American Express® CardNone$265$2651.98%
4American Express® Gold Card$325$587$2621.96%
5Citi Strata℠ CardNone$244$2441.83%
6Capital One Savor RewardsNone$240$2401.79%
7Chase Freedom Unlimited®None$232$2321.73%
8Blue Cash Preferred® Card from Amex$95$321$2261.69%
9Wells Fargo Autograph® CardNone$226$2261.69%
10Capital One Quicksilver Cash RewardsNone$201$2011.50%

Rank cards for your own spending

Your mix matters more than any average. Enter your monthly spending to see your own ranking.

Open the card value calculator →

Methodology

  • Spending: BLS Consumer Expenditure Surveys, 2025, Table 1: average annual expenditures of all consumer units (released October 29, 2026). Source. Mapped to reward categories as follows:
    • groceries: $6,491 a year — Food at home
    • dining: $4,142 a year — Food away from home
    • gas: $2,503 a year — Gasoline and other fuels
    • travel: $2,565 a year — Public and other transportation ($1,199) + other lodging ($1,366)
    • streaming: $0 a year — Not reported separately by BLS (included in entertainment, counted under everything else)
    • other: $11,065 a year — Housekeeping supplies ($844) + household furnishings and equipment ($2,355) + apparel and services ($2,010) + entertainment ($4,084) + personal care ($986) + drugs ($672) + reading ($114)
  • Excluded spending: Shelter, utilities, vehicle purchases and other vehicle expenses, health insurance and medical services, education, insurance and pensions, cash contributions, alcohol, tobacco and miscellaneous: these are usually not paid by credit card or not eligible for rewards.
  • Cards: personal credit cards whose annual fee and reward rates matched the issuer’s official page in our latest product verification (35 cards). Business cards are excluded.
  • Rewards: the same rewards model as our card comparison, including stated category caps. Points are valued at each card’s stated cents-per-point estimate (usually 1 cent), which is an assumption. Rotating categories, portal-only bonuses, statement credits and other benefits are not counted; see each card’s notes in the CSV.
  • Independence: the ranking is produced by the formula above. No issuer can pay to change it.

Use this data

Free to cite with a link to this page. Download the full ranking for all 35 cards (CSV). Contact us for a custom spending profile. See all SmartRates research.

Suggested citation: SmartRates, “Which credit card pays a typical household the most?” November 2026, https://smartratesusa.com/research/best-card-typical-household-2026

Estimates, not offers. Card terms change; confirm rates and fees on the issuer’s site before applying. See our advertiser disclosure.