Health Plan Cost Comparison Calculator

Compare two employer health plans across low-, medium-, and high-use years.

Free CalculatorπŸ“… Updated for 2026⚑ Instant results

Methodology review: November 18, 2026

Estimated annual costs

HSA-eligible HDHP costs $112.50 less.

  • HSA-eligible HDHP$3,720

    $1,440 premiums + $2,280 cost sharing

  • Lower-deductible PPO$3,832.50

    $2,640 premiums + $1,192.50 cost sharing

Budget limits and HSA deposits
HSA-eligible HDHPLower-deductible PPO
Premiums + in-network out-of-pocket limit$6,440$6,140
Employer HSA deposit$750$0

Budget figures cover eligible in-network care. Employer HSA deposits are separate from the estimated costs and budget figures.

Plan details

HSA-eligible HDHPLower-deductible PPO
Monthly employee premium ($)
In-network deductible ($)
Coinsurance you pay (%)
In-network out-of-pocket limit ($)
Annual employer HSA contribution ($)
Fixed office copay before and after deductible
Care assumptions Β· Medium use

Use covered, in-network allowed prices. Leave office visits out of other charges, and include only care subject to the main deductible and coinsurance.

The example compares an HSA-eligible HDHP and a lower-deductible PPO. A plan can be both an HDHP and a PPO.

How to Use the Health Plan Cost Comparison Calculator

  1. Use the same coverage tier and plan year for both plans. Enter what you pay in premiums from your enrollment materials.
  2. Copy the in-network deductible, coinsurance and out-of-pocket limit from each Summary of Benefits and Coverage.
  3. Enter a fixed office-visit copay only when it applies both before and after the deductible. Use negotiated allowed prices when estimating care.

Continue Your Financial Planning

Understand savings growth β†’Learn how APY, compounding, inflation, and account choice interact.Build a practical savings plan β†’Turn the calculation into automated monthly progress.Size an emergency fund β†’Decide how much liquid savings to keep available.

Related Guides

How to compare employer health plans β†’Find your plan inputs and follow the HDHP vs. PPO example.HSA Contribution and Tax Savings Calculator β†’Estimate HSA contribution room and tax savings for 2026 or 2027.

Sources and methodology

How SmartRates checks calculations Β· About the editorial team

πŸ“

Methodology

The estimate models one in-network deductible and one out-of-pocket limit. Covered charges subject to the deductible are paid up to that deductible, then at the entered coinsurance rate. Office visits with a fixed copay throughout the year bypass the deductible and count toward the out-of-pocket limit. Premiums are added separately. The model uses the same allowed prices for both plans. It excludes separate drug or family deductibles, copays that start only after the deductible, out-of-network and uncovered services, and tax effects.

Disclaimer: Calculations are for informational purposes only and do not constitute professional financial advice. Please consult with a certified professional before making financial decisions.